Nigeria: between health vigilance and a reshaping of the security apparatus Spécial

© TDR © TDR © TDR

In Nigeria, health surveillance is back in the spotlight as the Ebola epidemic, caused by the Bundibugyo strain of the virus, gains ground in Central and East Africa. After the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Uganda and Kenya, the evolution of the epidemic gives this threat a regional dimension and places border control measures at the heart of concerns. The detection of a first case in Nigeria has made these fears concrete, although the situation presents several areas of uncertainty. The patient who tested positive had returned from a two-week stay in Uganda, a country that had officially declared the end of its outbreak at the end of August. The exact origin of her infection, however, remains unknown. Now being treated in Switzerland, she could have been infected “anywhere”, according to the Director General of Africa CDC. He also criticised the inadequacy of health checks at borders, saying they were “not up to standard”. The difficulty in tracing the patient's path of infection thus illustrates the limits of surveillance mechanisms when movements between countries escape, even partially, control systems.

In this respect, it was this cross-border dimension that dominated discussions at the 28 October consultation, convened by the African Union's health authorities, where ministers examined ways to strengthen surveillance at points of entry, accelerate assistance to affected countries and improve the sharing of epidemiological information. The situation is all the more worrying as the threshold of 10,000 confirmed cases was crossed on 27 October, five months after the start of this new outbreak. The DRC accounts for the vast majority of infections, while the overall death toll is approaching 5,000. In Kenya, nine positive cases have been detected, resulting in two deaths. According to Africa CDC, the death rate is now twice that observed during the 2014-2016 West African epidemic. The organisation thus warned that “no country is currently safe”.

Beyond the rising toll, identifying transmission chains is one of the main obstacles to containing the disease. According to data presented at the meeting, 80% of new cases do not appear on contact lists, while up to 65% of deaths occur within communities. These proportions reflect the difficulties faced by health services in identifying infections early enough and breaking transmission chains. Nigeria, for its part, presented the measures taken to limit the risk of the virus being introduced. Health authorities are now working with customs and immigration services, while passengers on every flight to the country must complete an online health declaration to help identify possible suspected cases.

 

Disappearance of 37 artisanal gold miners in detention

As the Nigerian authorities seek to strengthen their tools for combating illegal mining, the methods used by some of the units tasked with this mission are the subject of fierce controversy. On 27 October, the commission of inquiry set up to shed light on the deaths of 37 people arrested in Niger State in September delivered findings directly implicating officers of the Mining Marshals, a paramilitary unit under the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps. The victims include 14 children. According to the inquiry's findings, the detainees died of suffocation after their cell was sprayed with an asphyxiating gas, revealing the seriousness of the conditions in which they were held.

The commission recommends the payment of overall compensation equivalent to 935,000 euros to the victims' families and the 44 survivors. It also recommends the summary dismissal of the commander of the Mining Marshals in Niger State, as well as of the other officers directly involved in the detention and deaths of the suspects. Beyond individual responsibilities, the report notes institutional failings and excessive zeal on the part of some officers, stressing the need for greater professionalism in the handling of suspects. Nigeria's Minister of the Interior, Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo, has pledged to implement the commission's recommendations. He notably ordered the immediate suspension of officers suspected of having cleaned the detention centre in order to destroy evidence.

This case highlights the contradictions that the Nigerian authorities may face in conducting their security operations. Illegal mining is a major issue for natural resource governance, particularly in gold-producing regions where clandestine activities largely escape regulatory mechanisms. Enforcement operations thus respond to economic and security concerns, in a country where some informal mining activities can feed criminal networks and contribute to financing armed groups.

Regional police forces: an institutional reform with blurred contours

On the domestic security front, Abuja is pursuing its plan to decentralise the police system, presented by the authorities as a way to better respond to persistent insecurity in the country. As of 30 October, 30 of the 36 state assemblies had ratified the constitutional amendment authorising the creation of regional police forces, thus well exceeding the required threshold of 24 states. The latest ratifications, notably by Lagos, Niger, Kogi and Ebonyi states, now make it possible to envisage the forthcoming transmission of the text to President Bola Tinubu for assent. The bill had already been approved by the Senate in June and by the House of Representatives in July. This progress marks an important step in a long-debated institutional project in Nigeria, where the centralisation of policing powers is regularly presented as a limit to the effectiveness of local security responses.

However, this constitutional reform does not mean that the new units will be immediately operational. A second piece of legislation is still needed to specify their respective powers and those of the federal police, whose continued existence is not in question. The division of competences, the arrangements for oversight by the central government and the coordination mechanisms between the different levels of policing remain to be defined. Differences between state assemblies over the extent of federal control illustrate the institutional difficulties that this new architecture could raise. The issue is all the more sensitive as the creation of regional forces implies redefining relations between Abuja and the state governments in a field traditionally considered the preserve of central authority.

In a country of some 240 million inhabitants, facing multiple threats ranging from jihadist groups to armed gangs, separatist movements and communal conflicts between farmers and herders, the reform aims to bring security resources closer to territorial realities. The authorities believe that better knowledge of local environments could make it possible to adapt police interventions to the forms of insecurity specific to each state. Pending the definition of concrete operating arrangements, Bola Tinubu's Chief of Staff, who heads the presidential task force on the project, has also called on the private sector to contribute financially to setting up the future regional units. He justifies this contribution by the economic consequences of insecurity, which directly affect productive activities and the country's development prospects.

Yet funding is only part of the questions raised by this reform. Recruitment conditions, the operational autonomy of the future units, their oversight and safeguards against possible political instrumentalisation will also need to be specified. While decentralisation may allow a police presence better suited to local realities, it requires sufficiently robust oversight mechanisms to avoid a proliferation of structures whose powers and responsibilities would be insufficiently defined. The question of the division of competences between the states and the central government therefore remains at the heart of this institutional transformation.



Évaluer cet élément
(0 Votes)
Dernière modification le lundi, 16 novembre 2026 11:54